Best Extra Wide Mary Jane Shoes for Toddlers – Cute and Easy to Put On

October 15, 2025 Extra Wide Shoes Juan Valenzuela 0 - Comments

Finding Mary Jane shoes that can fit toddlers with extra wide feet can be a challenging task. Most models end up being too narrow and squeezing the top part of the foot (instep). As a dedicated shoe fitter, I understand how crucial it is to find shoes that not only fit perfectly but also support your toddler’s developing feet. After having tested many different shoe brands and styles, I found one specific Mary Jane shoe that features actual extra wide widths, long Velcro straps for easy adjustability, and added depth to ensure your toddler’s feet sit comfortably inside the shoe without feeling squished.

The Mary Jane Shoes I Swear By: 5 Features That Make All the Difference

When selecting extra wide Mary Jane shoes for toddlers, there are five key features to consider:

Extra wide Mary Jane shoe with extra long Velcro straps.
These Mary Jane shoes feature extra-long Velcro straps that wrap comfortably around even the widest toddler feet and highest insteps — making them easy to secure without pinching or struggle.
Toddler Mary Jane shoes available in extra wide widths.
Available in True Extra Wide Widths — No guesswork, no ‘runs wide’ claims. The Mary Jane shoes I recommend come in actual extra wide sizes.
Toddler Mary Jane shoe with extra depth.
These extra wide Mary Jane shoes are crafted with added depth to ensure your toddler’s feet sit comfortably inside without feeling cramped. The deeper design helps protect the top of the foot (instep) and toes from rubbing against the front of the shoe
Extra wide Mary Jane shoe with rounded toe boxes.
The Mary Jane shoes I recommend feature extra-round toe boxes designed to give your toddler’s toes plenty of wiggle room—helping prevent uncomfortable overlapping and blisters.
Mary Jane shoe with oversized openings for easy on and off.
Mary Jane shoes with oversized openings make slipping extra-wide feet in and out a breeze.

Meet the Widest Mary Jane on the Market: The Stride Rite Holly

The Mary Jane shoe I’m excited to recommend is the Stride Rite Holly—a perfect blend of style and durability. Whether it’s a special occasion or a day full of play, Holly’s tough rubber outsole keeps up with your toddler’s every step. Plus, it looks adorable! Disclosure: Some links in this post may be affiliate links and we may receive a small commission (at no extra cost to you) when you click our links and make purchases.

Top Extra Wide Mary Janes for Toddlers: Stride Rite’s Holly

Stride Rite Holly Mary Jane in gold for girls.
Stride Rite adaptable silver Mary Jane for girls.

Key Features

  • Order the Mary Jane shoe Holly by Stride Rite on Zappos or Amazon
  • Available in extra wide widths
  • Awarded the Seal of Acceptance from the American Podiatric Medical Association (APMA)
  • Padded tongue and collar for added comfort
  • Supreme comfort care of Ortholite memory foam footbeds
  • Watch my full YouTube review to see this shoe in action and find out why it’s a great fit!
  • I suggest that you get this Mary Jane shoe a whole size larger than the end of your toddler’s longest toe

How to Find the Perfect Shoe Size Online

Getting the right fit is key to keeping your child’s feet comfortable and blister-free. That’s why I put together an easy-to-follow virtual guide to help families confidently choose the perfect shoe size when shopping online. Drawing from years of hands-on experience fitting kids’ shoes at a specialized children’s shoe store, this guide takes the guesswork out of sizing—so you can order with confidence every time.

Should Your Child Wear Socks with These Shoes? – Absolutely

Socks are a game-changer when it comes to keeping little feet comfy and blister-free. I always recommend pairing shoes with socks because they create a soft barrier that prevents rubbing and irritation. For toddlers with extra wide feet, seamless socks are the perfect choice—they give toes plenty of room to wiggle and move freely without feeling squeezed. It’s a simple step that makes a big difference in keeping your toddler’s feet healthy.

White crew seamless socks for kids.
  • Order these socks made by Jefferies on Amazon
  • Smooth toe seam provides less irritation and bulk for sensitive toes and feet
  • Made with premium ultra soft cotton
  • Quarter ribbed stay-up top is extra comfortable around ankles
Black seamless socks for kids.
  • Order these socks made by Jefferies on Amazon
  • Smooth toe seam provides less irritation and bulk for sensitive toes and feet
  • Made with premium ultra soft cotton
  • Quarter ribbed stay-up top is extra comfortable around ankles
Pink seamless socks for girls.
Black seamless socks for boys.
  • Order these socks made by Rambutan on Amazon
  • Odor Resistant Bamboo (Rayon)
  • Comfortable Comfort Seam Toe – Sensitive Toes Friendly (Hand Linked Toe)
  • Machine washable
Low-cut seamless socks for kids.
  • Order these socks made by Jefferies on Amazon
  • Smooth toe seam provides less irritation and bulk for sensitive toes and feet
  • Made with premium ultra soft cotton
  • Quarter ribbed stay-up top is extra comfortable around ankles

See My Top Mary Jane Shoe Picks in Action! – Watch My YouTube Video

Get an up-close look at these extra wide Mary Jane shoes for toddlers in my YouTube video! I’ll walk you through their standout features, benefits, and drawbacks.

Do These Mary Jane Shoes Work Well with Orthotics Such as AFOs?

Yes — they’re a great choice! Many parents ask if these shoes can accommodate orthotics like AFOs (ankle-foot orthotics), and the answer is a confident yes. With their rounded toe boxes, extra depth, removable insoles, and extra-long Velcro straps, these Mary Janes are thoughtfully designed to fit comfortably over most orthotics — all while keeping your toddler’s feet supported and stylish.

Reach Out with Any Questions

If you have any questions about fitting shoes for your child or need personalized recommendations, please feel free to reach out. I’m here to help you find the perfect pair of shoes that accommodates your toddler’s extra wide feet.

FAQ – Stride Rite Holly Extra Wide Mary Jane Shoes for Toddlers

1. Are Stride Rite Holly shoes machine washable?

Yes, Stride Rite Holly shoes are machine washable! However, it’s best to wash them only when necessary to preserve their shape and quality. Before tossing them in the washer, be sure to remove the memory foam insoles. The shoes also feature built-in odor-reducing linings, so frequent washing usually isn’t needed.

2. Are these shoes appropriate for early walkers?

Absolutely! The Stride Rite Holly shoes are perfect for early walkers — whether your toddler is just finding their balance or already walking with confidence. Designed with input from podiatrists, these shoes offer the right mix of support, flexibility, and comfort to promote healthy foot development during those crucial first steps.

3. What materials are used in the Stride Rite Holly shoes?

These shoes are made with a mesh fabric upper and a rubber sole.

4. Do these shoes run true to size?

These shoes tend to run a bit short. To ensure the best fit, I recommend ordering one full size up from your toddler’s longest toe. This gives them enough room to grow without compromising comfort or support.

5. Do these Mary Jane shoes provide arch support?

Not specifically — they don’t have built-in arch support. However, they do offer a stable base and firm heel counters, which help support proper alignment.

6. Do the sparkles on these shoes wear off?

Some parents have noticed that the glitter on these Mary Janes can sometimes flake or wear off with regular use.

Got questions or need help choosing the right fit? Drop a comment below — I’m happy to help!