Closed Toe Sandals for Toddler Girls – Stylish, Supportive, Flexible, and Durable!

There is a large selection of closed toe sandals for toddler girls, but how do you differentiate which ones are good for her feet? Parents want to have peace of mind that their children are wearing good quality shoes that are also the right size. Toddlers’ feet come in all different shapes and sizes, and if you want to prevent short- and long-term foot issues as well as posture problems, you need to make sure that your toddler wears the correct shoe at all times.

Some parents assume that they don’t need to invest in their toddler’s sandals as they wear them once in a while and for shorter periods of time. You might want to rethink this, as it only takes a couple of wears in the wrong shoe size or shoe style to develop a foot issue.

Not all toddler sandals are made the same. Some of them are made from higher quality materials and available in different widths such as medium (M), wide (W), and extra wide (XW).

Do More Expensive Shoes Translate Into Better Shoes for Your Child?

Please be careful of what type of shoes you provide for your toddler girl. I understand that some parents might be tempted to buy “cheaper” sandals for their toddlers in places such as Walmart or Target considering how fast children grow, but if your child happens to need glasses, would you buy them off the shelf instead of going to an optician?

More expensive shoes don’t necessarily translate into better shoes for your toddler, but it’s highly likely that they are going to be made of better materials and have been designed by a manufacturer who knows about the science of children’s feet. I am here to help you find a supportive pair of high-quality sandals for a reasonable price.

Let me start by clarifying that providing your toddler with poorly fitted or unsupportive shoes won’t deform your toddler’s feet, but this can lead to foot issues — blisters, calluses, corns — and advance any abnormalities that her feet may already have, such as flat feet.

Most toddlers need only one good pair of supportive and well-fitted shoes that they can wear as their everyday shoes. However, during the summer season, they need a pair of sandals to allow their feet to breathe and play in the water comfortably.

Are Any Good Fitting Children’s Shoe Stores Left?

I always recommend parents take their toddlers to their local shoe store, so they can have their feet properly measured and the shoes properly fitted. That is the reason why I created a resource that showcases the best fitting children’s local shoe stores by state.

If after looking at that resource you still can’t seem to find a good fitting children’s shoe store in your area, then keep on reading because I will show you a selection of the best closed toe sandals for toddlers’ girls.

What is the Advantage of Providing Toddlers with Closed-Toe Sandals?

The advantage of closed toe sandals is that they are going to protect your toddler’s toes at all times. However, you need to make sure that the sandals don’t cramp your toddler’s toes together or prevent your toddler from moving her toes. Toddlers move their toes as a way of exercising their feet, so you need to make sure that the sandals don’t constrict this movement.

Be Careful About Fitting Your Toddler in the Wrong Type of Sandals

Let me show you what can happen if you provide your toddler with a pair of sandals that have a pointy toe-box and are too narrow. Do you notice how the pinky toe (small toe) is being pushed to the side by the other toes? This can lead to foot issues such as blisters and corns.

It’s also important for your toddler’s sandals to provide extra depth to prevent the top part of your toddler’s feet — instep — from rubbing against the top part of the sandals. If you always notice imprints on the top of your toddler’s feet then it’s highly likely that your toddler has a high instep. Take a look at the image below to figure out where the instep of the foot is located:

What Makes the Closed-Toe Sandals that I Recommend Ideal for Toddlers?

1️⃣ Round Toe-Box: This feature is going to help prevent your kids’ toes from overlapping or rubbing against one another. Sandals with round toe-boxes also help prevent the child’s toes from rubbing against the side of the sandals.

2️⃣ Extra Depth: This feature is going to help prevent your child’s instep from rubbing against the top part of the sandals. Sandals with extra depth make it easy for children to get their feet on and off the sandals.

There are only a few closed-toe sandals that provide rounder toe-boxes and extra depth. These two features are going to help prevent your toddler’s toes from rubbing against one another or the side of the sandals.

The issue is that sandals don’t come labeled as “extra deep” or with a “rounder toe-box”, so the only way to tell if a sandal provides these 2 features is by having fitted the sandal before. Here is where I come into play, as I know exactly which sandals provide these 2 features from having fitted them before.

3 Additional Features of the Sandals that I Recommend

In addition to providing extra depth and rounder toe-boxes, your toddler’s sandals should provide the 3 following important features:

1️⃣ Support: Your toddler’s sandals must provide the correct amount of support while still being lightweight and flexible. The sandals that I recommend below will help keep your toddler’s feet and legs healthy by minimizing the impact that your toddler’s feet take every time they become in contact with the ground.

2️⃣ Fast-Dry Technology: Sandals that dry quickly help keep your toddler’s feet healthy. When the feet get wet for long periods of time the skin gets softer and more susceptible to developing foot issues such as blisters.

3️⃣ Good Traction: These sandals provide excellent traction to help prevent your toddlers from slipping and falling, especially when walking or running through wet surfaces.

How to Retrieve Your Toddler’s Exact Foot Length and Shape

Fit always remains a top priority, which brings me to this next question: Are you 100% sure of your toddler’s foot size? Ill-fitting sandals may lead to slips, trips, and falls, which can cause ankle damage among other foot issues. Follow the guidelines in the article below to figure out your toddler’s exact foot size from home.

Now that you know what features your toddler’s sandals must provide and how to figure out your toddler’s foot size from home, you are ready to take a look at a selection of the best closed toe sandals for toddler girls.

I only review shoes that I have fitted before, as that is the only way for me to tell how well-made the shoes are, the amount of support that they provide, and how they fit. Disclosure: Some links in this post may be affiliate links and we may receive a small commission (at no extra cost to you) when you click our links and make purchases.

Best Closed Toe Sandals for Toddler Girls 

Some of the sandals below are available in different widths such as medium (M), wide (W), and extra wide (XW), so please make sure that you choose your toddler’s foot width accordingly.

Many of the sandals featured below come in several color options, so if you want the sandals to be made of a specific color, please make sure to click through and see if they are available in that specific color.

Keep in mind that not all of the sandals that I recommend are not available in half sizes, so if your toddler happens to be in “between sizes” please order the larger size to allow for growing room. For example, let’s take a look at the following scenarios to help you figure out what sandal size your toddler needs:

  • If your toddler measures a foot size 6, then you should order the shoe size 7.
  • If your toddler measures a foot size 6 1/2, then you should order the shoe size 7.

Finding a pair of closed toe sandals for your toddler girl might not sound like a complicated thing to do, but finding a pair of closed toe sandals that are supportive, lightweight, flexible, durable, made from high-quality materials, and capable of fitting different foot shapes is another story.

Please remember that not all sandals are the same, and certain styles will fit the shape of your toddler’s foot shape better than others

If you need any other type of shoes such as everyday sneakers, winter boots, dress shoes, or sport shoes, you can find them all in a tool I created which lets you filter by the type of shoes you need. This tool is extremely effective since it will show you shoes in different widths such as narrow, medium, wide, and extra wide. I also tell you exactly how each shoe style fits — short, long, narrow, or wide — and will let you filter by the instep of your child’s foot.

Have you found a specific closed toe sandal that has worked well for your toddler’s feet? Please share your findings in the comments below so other families can benefit from your experiences.