Best Dress Shoes for Kids with Six Toes – Stylish, Extra Deep, and Rounder Toe-Boxes!

April 30, 2025 Extra Toes Juan Valenzuela 0 - Comments

Struggling to find dress shoes that comfortably fit your child’s extra toe? Many parents return multiple pairs, unsure whether the shoes they keep truly fit. Finding stylish, comfortable dress shoes for kids with six toes can feel overwhelming, as most standard shoes don’t offer the width or space needed. As a shoe fitter with over a decade of experience, I specialize in helping children with unique foot shapes—and I’m confident I can help your child find the perfect fit too.

Most Common Mistakes Parents Make: Stop Buying Longer Shoes

A common mistake parents make is buying shoes that are too long, thinking it will accommodate the extra toes. However, this can lead to an improper fit, causing the foot to slide forward and creating discomfort. Instead, focus on shoes with the right width and depth to ensure a proper fit. Longer shoes may seem like a solution, but they can cause problems such as tripping and awkward walking patterns.

Shoes that are too long can also lead to the development of blisters and other foot issues due to excess movement within the shoe. It’s essential to prioritize width and depth over length, ensuring the entire foot is supported and comfortable. This approach will help your child develop a natural and healthy gait, reducing the risk of injury and discomfort.

Key Shoe Features for Kids with Six Toes

Feature One: Extra Depth. Shoes with extra depth create valuable space inside, making them ideal for comfortably fitting extra toes. This added room helps reduce pressure across the top of the foot and prevents painful rubbing against the front of the shoe. In dress shoes, that extra depth can make all the difference in keeping your child’s feet supported, pain-free, and confident with every step.

Side-by-side image of two Mary Jane dress shoes—both the same size, but the See Kai Run shoe on the right offers noticeably more depth than the Naturino on the left.

Feature Two: Round Toe-Boxes. A round toe-box is another vital feature to look for in dress shoes for kids with six toes. The rounded design provides ample space for the toes to spread naturally, reducing the risk of cramping and discomfort. Unlike pointed or narrow toe-boxes, round toe-boxes do not squeeze the toes together, which is crucial for maintaining foot health. This design reduces the likelihood of developing corns or calluses.

Side-by-side image of two boys’ dress shoes—same size, but the See Kai Run shoe on the right features a rounder, more spacious toe-box than the Naturino on the left.

How to Identify Dress Shoes with These Two Features

Shoes aren’t labeled as “extra deep” or with “rounder toe-boxes,” so the only way to know if they offer these essential features is by experience. After fitting countless shoe brands and styles, I can confidently identify which dress shoes provide the extra depth and rounded toe-boxes your child needs.

My top recommendations for 2025 offer stylish and practical solutions for your child’s unique needs. Disclosure: Some links in this post are affiliate links, meaning I may earn a small commission (at no extra cost to you) if you make a purchase.

Dress Shoes for Kids with Six Toes – Extra Deep and Wide

While most of these dress shoes don’t come in wide (W) or extra wide (XW) widths, they’re specifically designed with extra depth and roomier, rounder toe-boxes—giving your child’s extra toe the space it needs to stay comfortable all day.

1. Berwyn by Florsheim

These wide dress shoes for six toes are available in wide widths, which makes them an excellent option for kids with extra toes. Known for their quality craftsmanship, these shoes offer both style and comfort, making them perfect for formal occasions.

Black dress shoes for boys with wide feet.
  • Order the dress shoe Loafer Church by French Toast on Zappos or Amazon
  • Available in medium and wide widths
  • Padded tongue and collar provide additional comfort and cushioning
  • Genuine leather
  • I suggest that you get this dress shoe a whole size larger than your child’s current foot size

2. Shoe style Holly Mary Jane by Stride Rite

These extra wide Mary Jane shoes by Stride Rite are a stylish option for kids with extra toes. With its roomy toe box and supportive design, it’s an ideal choice for girls needing a bit more width in their shoes.

Stride Rite Holly Mary Jane in gold for girls.
  • Order the Mary Jane shoe SR Holly by Stride Rite on Zappos or Amazon
  • Available in extra wide widths
  • Awarded the Seal of Acceptance from the American Podiatric Medical Association (APMA)
  • Padded tongue and collar for added comfort
  • Supreme comfort care of Ortholite memory foam footbeds
  • I suggest that you get this Mary Jane shoe a whole size larger than your child’s current foot size

3. Murphy by Stride Rite

This classic wide dress shoe is a fantastic choice for children with six toes as it provides ample room in the toe box and features a comfortable fit that supports your child’s foot shape. The classic design makes them suitable for a variety of settings.

Black dress shoes for boys with wide feet.
  • Order the dress shoe Murphy Sneaker by Stride Rite on Amazon or Zappos
  • Available in medium and wide widths
  • Lace-up closure
  • Premium leather with a padded heel collar
  • Memory-foam insole provides enhanced comfort 
  • I suggest that you get this dress shoe a whole size larger than your child’s current foot size

4. Mary Jane by FunkyMonkey

These wide fit Mary Jane shoes offer a playful twist on the classic design. They come in a range of colors and patterns, allowing your child to express their individuality while enjoying a comfortable fit.

Red patent toddler Mary Jane dress shoe.
  • Order the Mary Jane by FunkyMonkey on Amazon
  • Fits medium or wide feet
  • Velcro buckle secures the perfect fit every time
  • Lightly padded leather insoles
  • I suggest that you get this dress shoe a whole size larger than your child’s current foot size

5. Bogan Jr. by Florsheim

The Bogan Jr. by Florsheim is a great option for boys with six toes. These shoes are available in actual wide widths.

Black slip on dress shoes for kids with wide feet.
  • Order the dress shoe Soft Slip by Lonsoen on Amazon or Zappos
  • Available in medium and wide widths
  • Slip-on design
  • Made from soft PU leather material
  • I suggest that you get this dress shoe a whole size larger than your child’s current foot size

6. Claire by Stride Rite

This Mary Jane is available in extra wide widths and the classic design makes it suitable for various occasions.

Extra wide Mary Jane shoe for toddler girls.
  • Order the Mary Jane shoe Claire by Stride Rite on Amazon
  • Available in medium, wide, and extra wide widths
  • Crafted from a premium leather upper
  • Padded collar
  • I suggest that you get this dress shoe a whole size larger than your child’s current foot size

7. Lonsoen Lowfur

Lonsoen Lowfur shoes are an affordable option for parents looking for budget-friendly wide dress shoes. Despite their lower price point, they do not compromise on comfort or style.

Brown loafer for toddlers with wide feet.
  • Order the dress shoe Soft Slip by Lonsoen on Amazon
  • Fits medium or wide feet
  • Padded tongue and collar provide additional comfort and cushioning
  • 100% Synthetic 
  • I suggest that you get this dress shoe a whole size larger than your child’s current foot size

Contact Me for Specific Shoe Recommendations

If you’re feeling overwhelmed or unsure about which shoes to choose, don’t hesitate to reach out. I am here to provide personalized shoe recommendations based on your child’s unique foot shape and needs. Whether you’re looking for everyday sneakers or special occasion dress shoes, I can guide you towards the best options available.

Dress Socks for Kids with Six Toes – Stylish and Seamless

When it comes to dress socks, I recommend seamless options. They reduce friction, prevent irritation, and allow toes to move freely—ideal for children with extra toes or sensitive skin. Seamless socks offer extra comfort by eliminating the rubbing and pressure that traditional seams can cause.

Ankle socks for kids who wear Mary Jane shoes.
  • Order these socks made by Cotton Day on Amazon
  • 81% Combed Cotton, 17% Nylon, 2% Elastane
  • Seamless Toe (Hand Link Toe Seam)
  • Machine washable
Dress socks for kids with wide feet.
  • Order these socks made by Jefferies on Amazon
  • Premium ultra soft breathable cotton
  • Ultra smooth toe for added softness
  • Machine washable
Knee high socks for kids who wear Mary Jane shoes.
  • Order these socks made by Jefferies on Amazon
  • Available in multiple colors
  • 75% Acrylic, 25% Nylon
  • Classic and stylish cable knit knee high socks are perfect for school uniforms and dressing up 
  • Soft acrylic nylon blend is durable and comfortable for all day wear
  • Stay-up rib top provides no slipping or bunching so socks don’t fall down the legs
Seamless dress socks for kids with wide feet.
  • Order these socks made by Jefferies on Amazon
  • Ribbed leg design is stylish and provides a comfortable fit
  • Ultra smooth toe for added softness
  • Machine washable
Ruffle socks for kids who wear Mary Jane shoes.
  • Order these socks made by Jefferies on Amazon
  • 70% Cotton, 27% Nylon, 3% Spandex
  • Ribbed turn cuff top stays on ankles for all day wear
  • Three pair pack
Dress socks for boys.
  • Order these socks made by Jefferies on Amazon
  • 75% Combed Cotton, 23% Nylon, 2% Lycra Elastane
  • Seamless toe linking construction eliminates bulky toe seam
  • Machine washable

Find Out What Sock Size You Should Order

When choosing socks for your child, always go by the “shoe size” listed on the label—not “sock size” or age recommendations. This is the most accurate way to ensure a proper fit. See the image below for reference.

An image of a sock label highlighting why you should follow the “shoe size” guideline instead of the “sock size” for the best fit.

Bonus Resource: Everyday Sneakers for Kids with Six Toes

While dress shoes are important for special occasions, having a comfortable pair of everyday sneakers is equally essential. Sneakers designed with extra depth and round toe-boxes can provide the same level of comfort and support during daily activities. These shoes can be worn during play, school, or casual outings, ensuring your child’s feet are protected and comfortable no matter the occasion.

I’ve heard from many parents of children with six toes who are frustrated by how difficult it is to find shoes that fit. The challenge isn’t your child’s foot—there’s absolutely nothing wrong with having six toes. The real issue is that most shoes simply aren’t designed to accommodate extra width or toe space, making the search for the right pair feel nearly impossible.