Companies Allowing Purchase of Mismatched Shoe Sizes for Kids

June 22, 2025 Shoes for Different Sized Feet Juan Valenzuela 4 - Comments

Does your child have a noticeable size difference between their feet or wear an orthotic on only one side? Finding properly fitting shoes in these cases can be frustrating—and expensive—especially when most families are forced to buy two pairs just to get the right sizes. The good news? Some forward-thinking shoe companies now allow parents to purchase mismatched shoe sizes for kids, helping you save money without sacrificing fit or support. In this article, I’ll share which brands offer this option and how to take advantage of it.

How Do You Know If You Need to Buy Mismatched Shoe Sizes?

Reason One. If one of your child’s feet is only one full size longer than the other, mismatched shoes likely aren’t necessary. However, if there’s a size difference of 1.5 or more, split-sizing may be the best option. Some companies offer ‘split-size’ programs, allowing you to buy one shoe in a size 7 and the other in an 8½—without paying for two separate pairs.

Reason Two. Another common reason for needing mismatched shoe sizes is when a child wears an orthotic—like an AFO or SMO—on just one foot, creating a noticeable size or fit difference.

Is It Normal for One Foot to Be Bigger Than the Other in Kids?

Keep in mind that we all have a certain difference between our feet. One foot is always larger than the other. The issues arise when your child has a foot that is more than one and a half sizes bigger than the other one (or more).

Children with the following conditions are more prone to needing two different shoe sizes:

  • Spina Bifida
  • Club Foot
  • Cerebral Palsy
  • Polio
  • Children who wear AFOS

Companies That Let You Buy Mismatched Shoe Sizes for Kids

Children with disabilities already face enough challenges—finding properly fitting shoes shouldn’t be one of them. I’ve heard from many families who feel overwhelmed by the added expense of having to buy two pairs of shoes just to accommodate their child’s unique sizing needs. That’s why I put together a list of companies that let you purchase two different shoe sizes for the price of one—saving you money while ensuring your child gets the comfort and fit they deserve.

1. Nordstrom’s

  • You will order two pairs of shoes (one in each size, but they must be at least 1½ sizes different).
  • You will be charged for each pair and will be asked to send back the shoes that you do not need. Your credit card on file will get credited for the price of a pair.
  • If you have the need for only one shoe, a whole pair will be sent to you, and you will be asked to return the unneeded shoe.
  • Contact number (888) 282-6060

2. Zappos (No Longer Offers Mismatch Shoe Sizes)

3. One Foot Two Shoes

  • You can send the company your new, unused pairs or unpairs, sample shoes and/or mismatched pairs. You can then trade them in or consign them for cash.
  • If you are looking for a specific size, right or left, you can let the company know and they will be on the lookout and notify you when they are available.
  • If you have a bunch of shoes but only one in the pair you can ship the shoes to them.
  • Contact number (832) 460-0641 or email Info@onefoottwoshoes.com

4. Healthy Feet Store

  • This company offers a ”special discount program” for children who need mismatched odd size shoes.
  • Contact number 1.866.324.3338 or email cservice@healthyfeetstore.com

5. National Odd Shoe Exchange (N.O.S.E.)

  • To receive shoes you need to send an email stating what sizes your child needs. Be sure to include your address.
  • Contact information: P.O. Box 1120 Chandler, AZ 85244-1120 480-892-3484.

6. Birkenstock Express Online

  • This company offers a special discount for people who need only one shoe.
  • You can buy any regularly priced pair of shoes and they will discount it 40%.
  • Contact number 1-800-451-1459.

7. Billy Footwear

Consider reaching out to custom shoemakers who may be able to create shoes tailored to the specific needs of your child, including mismatched sizes.

Do Family Shoe Stores Provide Mismatched Shoe Sizes for Children?

Some independently owned family shoe stores offer a helpful discount—charging full price for the first pair and 40% off the second. These stores specialize in children’s footwear and take the time to properly measure your child’s feet, ensuring a personalized fit based on their unique foot shape and needs.

Don’t Allow Your Child to Wear Bigger Shoes in the Smaller Foot!

Letting your child wear a shoe that’s too big for their smaller foot might seem like a simple solution, but it can actually cause serious problems. Oversized shoes can lead to foot deformities, discomfort, and instability. In active kids, it can even increase the risk of injury and hinder performance in sports or play. Prioritizing the right fit for each foot is essential for healthy development and comfort.

Find Your Child’s “Shoe Mate”!

If you don’t have access to the stores listed, drop your child’s shoe sizes in the comments below—you might find a perfect “sole mate”! For example, if your child wears a size 9 on the left and a 7 on the right, you’ll want to connect with someone whose child has the reverse. It’s also a great way to remind your child that they’re not alone—many others are on the same journey.