Extra Wide Mary Jane Shoes for Kids – They Do Exist!

February 27, 2025 Durable Shoes Juan Valenzuela 4 - Comments

As a passionate shoe fitter with years of experience, I know firsthand how challenging it can be to find the perfect pair of Mary Jane shoes for kids with extra wide feet. Have you ever struggled to find a pair that actually fits, only to notice red marks or indentations on the top part of your child’s feet? It’s frustrating, I get it! But don’t worry—there are extra wide Mary Jane shoes out there specifically designed to provide extra depth, round toe-boxes, and oversized openings for easy on and off. Plus, many are available in extra wide widths (X-Wide), offering a better fit and comfort for your child’s extra wide feet.

Most Common Mistakes Parents Make

One of the biggest mistakes many parents make is simply sizing up their child’s shoes until they stop complaining about them being too tight. While it might seem like a quick fix, this can actually lead to more problems! When the shoes are too loose, your child’s feet will move around inside, creating friction with every step. This constant rubbing can result in painful foot issues like blisters, calluses, and discomfort. It’s important to find the right fit—not just the bigger fit—to keep your child’s feet happy and healthy.

An image of a pair of white Mary Jane shoes with round toe-boxes.

Another common mistake I see parents make is assuming that just because a pair of Mary Jane shoes is labeled “extra wide” (XW), they will automatically fit their child’s extra-wide feet perfectly. Unfortunately, it’s not that simple! To truly provide the right fit, Mary Jane shoes need to also provide extra depth, round toe-boxes, and oversized openings.

Key Features of Mary Jane Shoes for Kids with Extra Wide Feet

1. Extra Depth: This feature allows your children’s feet to fit deeply inside the shoes and prevents the top part of their feet from rubbing against the top part of the shoes.

By offering more vertical space, these shoes prevent the foot from feeling compressed, which can lead to discomfort or even pain over time.

2. Rounder Toe-Boxes: A round toe-box offers enough room for the toes to spread naturally, promoting healthy foot development. This design helps prevent issues such as bunions or calluses, which can occur when toes are crammed into a narrow space.

The difference in toe-boxes between two pairs of Mary Jane shoes that are the same size in length.

3. Oversized Openings: This feature is going to make it easier for parents and children to get the Mary Jane shoes on and off:

Mary Jane shoes with oversized openings for kids who wear AFOs.
Oversized openings can be a lifesaver for busy parents and active kids, reducing the hassle of getting ready.

Do the Mary Jane Shoes I Recommend Fit High Insteps?

High insteps can be another challenge when finding the right shoes for your child. Children with high insteps require shoes that offer sufficient vertical space to avoid pressure on the top of the foot. Fortunately, the Mary Jane shoes listed above are designed with adjustable closures, which help accommodate high insteps.

Child with a high instep.
The instep is the top part of the foot, and when children have high insteps there is a lot of extra foot volume that we need to fit inside the shoes.

Are Mary Jane Shoes Available in Extra Wide Widths?

Yes, I’ve fitted several Mary Jane styles that are labeled as extra wide (XW), but here’s the good news—there are also some fantastic options that naturally fit wide, even if they’re not labeled as extra wide!

After thorough research and fitting trials, I’ve compiled a list of the best extra wide Mary Jane shoes that provide both comfort and style for kids. Disclosure: Some links in this post may be affiliate links and we may receive a small commission (at no extra cost to you) when you click our links and make purchases.

Best Extra Wide Mary Jane Shoes for Kids That Fit High Insteps

Take a look at the description below each Mary Jane shoe I recommend to find out if it comes labeled as wide or extra wide. If the shoe is not labeled as wide (W) it’s because it provides extra depth and rounder toe-boxes. 

1. Holly Mary Jane by Stride Rite

These extra wide Mary Jane shoes by Stride Rite are a stylish option. With its roomy toe box and supportive design, it’s an ideal choice for girls needing a bit more width in their shoes.

Stride Rite Holly Mary Jane in gold for girls.

Key Features

  • Order the shoe style SR Holly by Stride Rite on Zappos or Amazon
  • Available in extra wide widths
  • Awarded the Seal of Acceptance from the American Podiatric Medical Association (APMA)
  • Padded tongue and collar for added comfort
  • Supreme comfort care of Ortholite memory foam footbeds
  • I suggest that you get this Mary Jane shoe a whole size larger than your child’s current foot size

2. Mary Jane by FunkyMonkey

These wide fit Mary Jane shoes offer a playful twist on the classic design. They come in a range of colors and patterns, allowing your child to express their individuality while enjoying a comfortable fit.

Red patent toddler Mary Jane dress shoe.

Key Features

  • Order the shoe style by FunkyMonkey on Amazon
  • Fits wide and extra wide feet
  • Velcro buckle secures the perfect fit every time
  • Lightly padded leather insoles
  • I suggest that you get this shoe a whole size larger than your child’s current foot size

3. Claire by Stride Rite

These extra wide Mary Jane shoes have a classic design that make them suitable for various occasions. They are perfect for everyday wear or school.

Extra wide Mary Jane shoe for toddler girls.
  • Order the shoe style Claire by Stride Rite on Amazon
  • Available in extra wide widths
  • Crafted from a premium leather upper
  • Padded collar
  • I suggest that you get this shoe a whole size larger than your child’s current foot size

4. Holly by Stride Rite

These extra wide width Mary Jane shoes are a fantastic choice for kids with extra wide feet, featuring extra-long Velcro straps for an adjustable fit.

Stride Rite adaptable silver Mary Jane for girls.

Key Features

  • Order the shoe style SR Holly by Stride Rite on Amazon
  • Available in extra wide widths
  • I suggest that you get this shoe a whole size larger than your child’s current foot size

5. Susie by See Kai Run

These extra wide Mary Jane shoes are designed with extra depth, wide toe boxes, and flexible outsoles, allowing natural movement. The soft leather material is gentle on the skin, reducing the risk of irritation. With its cute design, this Mary Jane offers the ideal blend of support and style for children with extra wide feet.

See Kai Run Mary Jane for toddlers learning how to walk.
Extra wide Mary Jane shoe for kids by See Kai Run.

Key Features

  • Order the shoe style by See Kai Run on Amazon or Zappos
  • Fits wide and extra wide feet
  • 100% leather
  • Padded collar for comfort
  • Patent leather uppers with scalloped topline edging
  • I suggest that you get this Mary Jane shoe a whole size larger than your child’s current foot size

6. Nell by Stride Rite

These extra wide fit Mary Jane shoes by Stride Rite provide both style and functionality, making them the perfect choice for children who need a shoe that accommodates extra wide feet.

Stride Rite Mary Jane for kids with wide or extra wide feet.

Key Features

  • Order the shoe style Nell by Stride Rite on Zappos or Amazon
  • Available in wide widths
  • Velcro closure
  • Padded collar for comfort
  • Removable contoured footbed
  • I suggest that you get this Mary Jane shoe a whole size larger than your child’s current foot size

Contact Me to Get a Personalized Recommendation

As a dedicated shoe fitter, my goal is to help you find the perfect pair of shoes for your child’s extra wide feet. I understand that every child’s needs are unique, and I’m here to provide support and guidance throughout your shoe selection process. If you have specific concerns or questions, feel free to contact me for a personalized recommendation.

How to Check If Your Kids’ Mary Jane Shoes Are Too Narrow?

There is an easy and effective way to check if your kids’ Mary Jane shoe styles are too narrow. Slide your finger around the top part of your child’s feet (instep) where the front part of the Mary Jane shoe meets with your kids’ feet. Take a look at the image below for clarification purposes:

How to check if your kids’ Mary Jane shoes fit correctly.

You should be able to comfortably slide your finger around this area. If you can’t fit your finger, then it means that the Mary Jane shoe is too narrow.

Other Signs that Mary Jane Shoes Might Be Too Narrow

Red Marks: Check for red marks or pressure spots on your child’s feet after wearing the shoes. These marks indicate areas where the shoe is rubbing against the skin, which can lead to more severe issues if not addressed.

Child with imprints on the top part of his foot from wearing shoes that were fitted too narrow.
An image of a child with imprints on the top part of her foot.

Complaints of Discomfort: Pay attention if your child frequently complains about tightness or discomfort. Children may not always articulate their discomfort directly, so it’s essential to observe their behavior, such as reluctance to wear the shoes.

Find out the reason why your toddler keeps taking his or her shoes off.
An image of a child complaining that the shoes feel too tight.

Toe Overlap: Ensure the toes are not overlapping or crammed within the toe-box. Overlapping toes can lead to long-term deformities and pain, affecting your child’s ability to walk comfortably and confidently.

Image of a child's foot with overlapping toes.
An image of a child with the second toe overlapping the big toe.

Can Mary Jane Shoes Be Worn As Everyday Sneakers?

Yes, because the styles that I recommend all provide good support and they are all made from high-quality materials which makes them very durable. However, Mary Jane shoes should never replace your child’s every day sneakers.

Sneakers offer additional support and cushioning, making them a great everyday option. They are versatile, suitable for both school and play, and are available in various styles to match your child’s personality. I’ve compiled a comprehensive guide to help you explore the best options for extra-wide sneakers for girls.

Mary Jane shoes are a classic choice for children, offering both style and comfort. Known for their simple design, typically characterized by a strap across the instep, these shoes have been a staple in children’s wardrobes for decades. Have you tried another Mary Jane shoe style that has worked well for your child’s extra wide feet? Please share your findings below so other parents can benefit from your experiences.