Best Shoes for Kids with High Insteps: Why Sizing Up Doesn’t Work

Last updated: November 12, 2026 · By Juan Valenzuela, Certified Children’s Shoe Fitter


“These shoes are too small.” It’s one of the most common things I hear from parents in fittings, and very often the shoes aren’t too small at all. The length is right, the width is right, but the shoe still squeezes, leaves red marks on top of the foot, and is a battle to get on. The real problem is a high instep, and the usual fix, buying a bigger size, makes things worse. As a certified children’s shoe fitter, I’ll show you how to tell whether your child has a high instep, how to check if a shoe is deep enough, and which shoes I recommend by type.


Is It a High Instep or Just the Wrong Size?

A high instep is a tall, rounded top of the foot, between the toes and the ankle. Most kids’ shoes are made for an average foot height, so a high instep fills the shoe from top to bottom, even when the length and width are correct.


What a High Instep Looks Like

There’s no device that measures instep height, so the best way to check is to look at your child’s foot from the side while they stand barefoot.

A child with a high instep standing barefoot, seen from the side.
Child's feet with high insteps.
A child’s feet with high insteps, standing barefoot. Notice the tall, rounded top of the foot.
Child's foot with a high instep.
Side view of a child’s foot with a high instep. Another example of a high instep.

For more examples, see my guide on how to tell if your child has a high instep.


High Instep vs. High Arch

Parents often mix these up. A high arch is on the bottom of the foot: the inside of the foot curves up off the ground. A high instep is on top of the foot. They often go together, but not always. A high arch mostly affects support and cushioning, while a high instep affects how deep the shoe needs to be.


Why Buying a Bigger Size Doesn’t Work

When shoes feel tight on top, it’s natural to go up a size. But a bigger size adds mostly length, not depth. The result:

  • The shoe is still tight on top, because it’s barely taller
  • The extra length makes your child trip and catch their toes
  • The heel slips out, which causes blisters
  • The shoe bends in the wrong place, because the flex point no longer lines up with your child’s toes

What a high instep needs is your child’s correct size in a deeper shoe.


How to Check If a Shoe Is Deep Enough

Do this check when you try on new shoes, or with the shoes your child wears now:

  1. The on test. With the straps or laces fully open, your child should be able to slide their foot in without you forcing it.
  2. The pinch test. Once the shoe is fastened, gently pinch the top of the shoe over the instep. You should be able to grab a little bit of material. If it’s stretched tight, the shoe isn’t deep enough.
  3. The strap test. Velcro straps should close with plenty of overlap, and laces shouldn’t have to be pulled to the very ends.
  4. The 30-minute test. After your child wears the shoes for 30 minutes, take them off and look at the top of the foot. Red marks or indentations mean the shoe is pressing down.

What to Look for in Shoes for High Insteps

Extra Depth

More room between the sole and the top of the shoe is the most important feature. In the photo below, both shoes are the same length and width, but one is much deeper.

Two kids’ shoes in the same length and width, one noticeably deeper for a high instep. Same length, same width, but one shoe has much more depth.

A Wide Opening

The shoe should open far down toward the toes, so the foot slides in without bending.

A pair of See Kai Run sneakers with oversized openings for easy on and off.
See Kai Run kids’ shoe with double Velcro straps that open wide for a high instep. Double straps that open wide make it easy to get a high instep in.

Adjustable Straps or Laces

Two or three straps, or laces, let you loosen the shoe over the instep and tighten it everywhere else.

Adidas toddler shoes with oversized openings for easy on and off.
Kids’ sneakers with double Velcro straps for easy on and off with a high instep.

A Removable Insole

Taking out the insole adds depth instantly, and gives you room for an orthotic if your child needs one.


High Instep with Narrow or Medium Feet

Many parents assume a high instep means they need a wide shoe, but a child can have a narrow or medium foot that’s tall on top. A wide shoe would let their foot slide around. Instead:

  • Stay in your child’s true width and look for depth, a wide opening, and adjustable closures
  • Choose laces or multiple straps, so you can loosen the top and keep the heel snug
  • Change the lacing. Skipping the cross over the instep relieves pressure without loosening the rest of the shoe. My high instep lacing guide shows you how.

Best Shoes for Kids with High Insteps

I’ve fit all of these shoes on kids with high insteps. Disclosure: some links in this post are affiliate links — I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

574 by New Balance

A classic sneaker with a wide hook-and-loop opening and good depth. Because it comes in medium, wide, and extra wide, it works for almost any foot shape with a high instep.

Key Features


See Kai Run Russell (Boys) and Robyne (Girls)

Lightweight, flexible toddler shoes with a wide opening. They come in one width but are cut naturally roomy, with depth for a high instep.

Blue and purple See Kai Run kids shoes with double Velcro straps displayed side by side. Designed for children with wide feet, these supportive sneakers provide easy on-and-off access and a comfortable fit.

Key Features

  • Order on Amazon
  • Sizes: toddler and little kid
  • Widths: medium only, but fits wide
  • APMA Seal of Acceptance
  • Padded tongue and collar, breathable lining, cushioned insole
  • Size to order: 1 full size up

990v6 by New Balance

The deepest, most supportive sneaker I fit for high insteps. Its firm heel counter and stable base also make it a strong choice for kids who pronate (whose feet roll inward). It’s the most expensive pick, but it’s very durable.

Key Features

  • Order with laces on the New Balance website or Amazon
  • Velcro version also available on the New Balance website or Amazon
  • Sizes: toddler, little kid, and big kid
  • Widths: medium, wide, and extra wide
  • Firm heel counter and stable base, good for moderate to strong pronation
  • Removable insole for extra depth or an orthotic
  • Size to order: ½ size up

Ikiki Shoes

A soft toddler shoe with a wide opening that makes it easy to get a high instep in, even for wiggly little ones.

Key Features

  • Order on Amazon
  • Sizes: toddler and little kid
  • Widths: medium only, but fits wide
  • Synthetic (vegan) leather upper
  • Squeaker you can turn on or off
  • Size to order: 1 full size up

See Kai Run Lucia Mary Jane

Most Mary Janes are shallow, with a single strap that presses right on the instep. The Lucia has more depth, making it a good choice for parties and school uniforms.

Black patent and silver See Kai Run Mary Jane shoes displayed side by side. Designed to fit children with wide feet, these dress shoes provide a roomy fit, secure adjustable strap, and all-day comfort.

Key Features

  • Order on Amazon
  • Sizes: toddler and little kid
  • Widths: medium only, but fits wide
  • APMA Seal of Acceptance
  • Cotton upper, leather insole, recycled mesh lining
  • Size to order: 1 full size up

Fresh Foam 650 by New Balance

A cushioned everyday sneaker with extra depth, an oversized opening, and a round toe box, available in lace-up and Velcro styles.

Navy and lavender New Balance lace-up kids sneakers displayed side by side. Available in wide and extra wide widths, these lightweight sneakers provide a comfortable, supportive fit for children with wider feet.
Navy and lavender New Balance kids sneakers with Velcro straps displayed side by side. Available in wide and extra wide widths, these supportive sneakers provide a comfortable fit for children with wider feet.

Key Features

  • Order on Amazon or the New Balance website
  • Also available with laces on Amazon
  • Sizes: toddler, little kid, and big kid
  • Widths: medium, wide, and extra wide
  • Size to order: 1 full size up

Velocity and Rainbow by Tsukihoshi

Lightweight, machine-washable sneakers with a roomy forefoot and padded collar. They run wider than a standard medium and fit long, so order your child’s current size.

Tsukihoshi Rainbow and Velocity shoes for kids with hook-and-loop straps.

Key Features

  • Order the Velocity or the Rainbow model on Amazon
  • Sizes: toddler, little kid, and big kid
  • Width: runs wider than a standard medium
  • Padded tongue and collar
  • Machine-washable synthetic leather and mesh upper
  • Size to order: same as your child’s current foot size (it fits long)

Rave Run v2 by New Balance

A lightweight running shoe with extra depth and a bungee lace with a top strap, at an affordable price.

Available in medium, wide, and extra wide widths, these lightweight sneakers provide a comfortable fit for different foot shapes.

Key Features

  • Order the Velcro version on the New Balance website or Amazon
  • Sizes: toddler, little kid, and big kid
  • Widths: wide and extra wide
  • Breathable mesh upper
  • Padded collar and tongue
  • Size to order: 1 full size up

Cross Em Up by Adidas

A high-top basketball shoe with ankle support and a roomy fit, for active kids who need a sport shoe with extra depth.

Key Features

  • Order on Amazon
  • Sizes: little kid and big kid
  • Widths: medium and wide
  • High-top ankle support, good for mild to moderate pronation
  • For sports and everyday wear
  • Size to order: 1 full size up

Fresh Foam Arishi v4 by New Balance

A cushioned, lightweight sneaker with a semi-firm heel counter, at a reasonable price. It comes in medium, wide, and extra wide, in lace-up and bungee-strap styles.

Key Features


M2P Journey 3.0 Adapt by Stride Rite

A supportive leather toddler shoe in extra wide, for little ones who have a high instep and very wide feet.

Key Features

  • Order on Amazon
  • Sizes: toddler
  • Width: extra wide
  • APMA Seal of Acceptance
  • Leather upper
  • Size to order: ½ size up

Find Your Child’s Size at Home

Ordering online? My guide to measuring your kid’s feet shows you how to find your child’s foot length and width in two simple steps. Remember: order based on their foot size, not on how tight their old shoes felt on top.


Need a Specific Recommendation?

Every child’s foot is different. Email me with your child’s foot length and width (narrow, medium, wide, or extra wide), what the shoes are for, and where you live, and I’ll suggest the styles most likely to work.


More Shoes for High Insteps


FAQ

How do I measure my child’s instep?

There’s no device that measures instep height. Look at your child’s foot from the side while they stand barefoot, and use the depth check above. If shoes are tight on top but have room at the toes, it’s a high instep.

Should I buy a bigger size for a high instep?

No. A bigger size adds length, not depth, so the shoe stays tight on top and becomes too long. Buy your child’s correct size in a deeper shoe.

Can a child with narrow feet have a high instep?

Yes. Stay in their true width and choose a shoe with depth, a wide opening, and laces or multiple straps, so the heel stays snug while the top has room.

Is a high instep the same as a high arch?

No. A high arch is on the bottom of the foot, and a high instep is on top. They often go together, but a high instep is what makes shoes tight on top.

Are Crocs good for high insteps?

They’re roomy, but they don’t offer much support, so I don’t recommend them for everyday wear.